St. Louis, MO – May 2, 2025
In a stunning development that has left fans reeling, the St. Louis Cardinals are preparing for a new era after two of their most prominent players — All-Star third baseman Nolan Gorman and ace pitcher Miles Montgomery — officially announced their departures from the team.
Gorman, 25, who emerged as one of the National League’s most powerful hitters over the past three seasons, confirmed late Wednesday night that he has been traded to the Seattle Mariners in a blockbuster deal involving multiple prospects and future draft picks. Just hours later, Montgomery, the Cardinals’ Opening Day starter and a rising star on the mound, revealed his intention to opt out of his contract and enter free agency.
“It’s a tough day for Cardinals Nation,” said President of Baseball Operations John Mozeliak. “These aren’t just two of our best players — they’re two cornerstones. But in today’s game, these moments come. And now, we turn the page.”
Gorman’s exit, in particular, hits hard. Drafted by the Cardinals in 2018, he became a fan favorite thanks to his consistent power at the plate and clutch performances in key moments. In 2024, he led the team with 39 home runs and 112 RBIs, earning his second consecutive All-Star nod and helping keep St. Louis in playoff contention through a turbulent season.
“This city raised me,” Gorman said in a farewell message posted to social media. “I’ll always be grateful to the Cardinals organization, my teammates, and the fans. But I’m excited for this new opportunity and what lies ahead in Seattle.”
Montgomery’s decision, while less surprising, still carries weight. The 28-year-old right-hander had a breakout campaign in 2024, posting a 2.87 ERA with 198 strikeouts in 31 starts. With his value at an all-time high, Montgomery is expected to command a major contract in free agency — possibly north of $150 million.
“I’ve loved my time in St. Louis,” Montgomery said. “This team and these fans have meant everything to me. But it’s time to explore what’s next.”
The double departure leaves the Cardinals with major questions heading into the 2025 season. Though the return package for Gorman includes two highly touted infield prospects and a top pitching arm, it may be years before those players are ready to contribute at the big-league level.
Meanwhile, the loss of Montgomery strips the rotation of its top-tier anchor. Young pitchers like Tommy Rojas and Kyle Mattingly will be under pressure to step up, while the front office will likely pursue veteran arms in free agency.
“This is a pivot point,” said Cardinals beat writer Jenna Morales. “These moves don’t mean the Cardinals are waving a white flag, but they clearly signal a shift in direction — possibly a retooling rather than a full rebuild.”
For fans, the news has brought a mix of sadness and uncertainty.
“They were the heart of this team,” said season ticket holder Frank Delaney. “It’s hard to imagine Opening Day without Gorman at third and Montgomery on the mound.”
As St. Louis enters a crucial offseason stretch, one thing is certain: the departures of Nolan Gorman and Miles Montgomery have reshaped the franchise’s immediate future — and left a hole that won’t easily be filled.
